EARLY PAPER
Convertible Note or SAFE: What Changes When You Sign One
A convertible note is a loan with a maturity date and a SAFE is not, but the valuation cap does more to your ownership than either name ever will.
Both documents exist for the same reason: you and your investor cannot agree on what the company is worth today, and neither of you wants to spend two months and a pile of legal fees finding out. So you postpone the argument. Money goes in now, ownership gets settled later, at the price a future round establishes.
The difference between them is short enough to say in one line. A convertible note is a loan. A SAFE is not. The note has an interest rate and a maturity date, which means there is a day when somebody can ask for the money back. The SAFE has neither, which means it sits on your cap table indefinitely, waiting for a priced round that may or may not arrive.
Everything else follows from that.
What a convertible note does
A note is debt until the moment it converts. It accrues interest, usually at a modest rate, and that accrued interest converts into shares along with the principal. It has a maturity date, commonly a year or two out, and the document says what happens when that date arrives.
Read that clause carefully, because there are several versions of it. Some notes automatically extend. Some convert at a stated valuation. Some become payable on demand, which means an investor can ask a company with no profit for its money back at exactly the moment it has none. That is rarely what anyone intends at signing, and it is a real position to be in when the maturity date lands during a slow quarter.
Until conversion, the note sits above all equity in the stack. If the company winds down before a priced round, note holders line up with creditors and shareholders get what is left, which is generally nothing.
There is a second clause worth finding before you sign, usually a few lines further down. It says what happens if the company gets acquired before any priced round. Some documents repay the holder a multiple of their money at closing. Others convert them at the cap and let them participate as a shareholder in the sale. Those two outcomes can differ by a large amount on the same transaction, and the choice between them was made in a paragraph drafted at a moment when nobody in the room was thinking about being acquired.
What a SAFE does
A SAFE is an agreement for future equity. It is not a loan, there is no interest, and there is no maturity date. Nothing comes due, ever. It converts when a priced equity round happens, or when the company is sold, or on a few other defined events.
The tradeoff is that the waiting can be permanent. A company that grows steadily on its own revenue and never raises a priced round can carry SAFEs for years, and every new hire looking at the cap table sees an amount of future dilution nobody can pin down yet.
The version you sign matters more than the form's name. A post-money SAFE fixes the holder's ownership as a percentage of the company at conversion. A pre-money SAFE does not. With post-money paper, if you sell 10 percent on a SAFE, that holder gets 10 percent, and every later SAFE you sell dilutes you rather than them. Sell four of those and you have committed a defined block of your company without ever seeing it appear on a cap table.
The cap and the discount
Two terms decide the price, and they exist because early money should not convert at the same price as money that shows up after you have proved something.
A discount gives the holder a percentage off the price the new round pays. Twenty percent off a 2.00 dollar share means they convert at 1.60.
A valuation cap sets a ceiling on the valuation used to price their conversion, regardless of what the priced round says. A cap is the term that actually does the work, and it is worth more attention than the discount.
Work it through. You raise 400,000 dollars on a SAFE with a 4,000,000 post-money cap. Eighteen months later you price a round at 8,000,000 post-money. The SAFE converts at its cap, so the holder's stake is 400,000 divided by 4,000,000, or 10 percent of the company. A new investor putting in 1,000,000 at the 8,000,000 valuation takes 12.5 percent. You and your existing holders split what remains, which is 77.5 percent.
Now raise the same 400,000 on a SAFE with an 8,000,000 cap instead. That holder converts at 5 percent rather than 10, and you keep five additional points. The check was identical. The cap did all of it.
That is why a founder who negotiates hard on the headline of a priced round and shrugs at the cap on an early SAFE has the priorities backwards. The cap is the valuation. It is just a valuation you agreed to before you had to.
One more term travels with this paper and rarely gets explained. A most favored nation clause gives its holder the benefit of any better terms you grant a later investor on a similar instrument. Sign one of those, then sign a second SAFE at a lower cap to get a deal closed, and the first holder's cap drops to match. The clause is reasonable on its face. It is worth knowing about before you reach for a low cap as a closing tool.
The stacking problem
Here is the part that surprises people, and it is the strongest argument for keeping this paper simple.
SAFEs and notes are easy to sign one at a time. An investor commits, the document is short, the money arrives in a week. Then it happens again, at a different cap, and again on a slightly different template, and by the time you are pricing a round there are eight instruments converting at once, at four different prices, some with discounts that interact with caps in ways nobody modeled.
Your lawyer will model it eventually. The problem is that it gets modeled during the priced round, when you have the least ability to do anything about the answer.
Keep a single spreadsheet from the first instrument. One row per holder: amount, date, cap, discount, whether it is pre-money or post-money, and which template. Then run the conversion at two hypothetical valuations, a good one and a mediocre one, and look at where you land. Ten minutes of arithmetic after every signing, and you never get surprised by your own paperwork.
Which one to sign
If you need the money and the investor has a form they use, take their form and argue about the cap.
If you have a choice, the honest comparison is this. A note gives the investor a maturity date, which is a form of pressure on you, and gives you a position above equity in a wind-down, which protects them. A SAFE removes both. Neither is generous or predatory by itself. A SAFE with a low cap costs you far more than a note with a high one, and the document type tells you nothing about which you are holding.
One practical note on amounts. Both instruments were designed for a bridge rather than for a business plan. Raising a modest amount on a SAFE to reach a specific milestone is the job the form was built for. Raising several times that across a dozen signatures, over two years, at four different caps, is a priced round assembled by accident, with none of the disclosure and none of the cap table discipline a real round forces on everybody.
Read the cap first. Read the maturity clause second. And write down, before you sign, the percentage of your company that instrument converts into at a valuation you would consider a decent outcome. If that number makes you uncomfortable on paper, it will not feel better in two years when it shows up on a cap table in front of a new investor.
Common questions
is a safe better than a convertible note for a founder
Neither is better by type. A SAFE removes the maturity date and the interest, which takes pressure off you, while a note keeps both, which protects the investor. A SAFE with a low valuation cap costs you far more ownership than a note with a high one.
what happens to a convertible note at maturity
It depends on the clause in your own document. Some notes extend automatically, some convert at a stated valuation, and some become payable on demand. Find that paragraph before you sign, because the last version lets an investor ask for cash at the worst possible moment.
what is a valuation cap on a safe
It is a ceiling on the valuation used to price that holder's conversion, whatever the eventual priced round says. A lower cap converts into a larger share of your company. It does more work than any other term on the page, so negotiate it harder than the discount.