The Capital Stack Room Who gets paid first, and what that position costs.

The Capital Stack Room

CAP TABLE

Cap Table Hygiene Before Your First Outside Round

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

A first outside round tends to die in diligence rather than in the pitch, so here are the cap table defects to clear before anybody asks to see it.

Rounds do not usually die in the pitch. They die about three weeks later, in diligence, when a lawyer asks who owns the shares and the answer takes eleven days to assemble and still has a hole in it.

A cap table is not a spreadsheet. It is a claim about who legally owns your company, and every line on it has to trace back to a signed document and, where the shares were purchased, evidence that money changed hands. When a line cannot be traced, the deal does not fail dramatically. It slows down, the terms drift, and the investor develops a quiet view of how you run things.

Fixing this takes a few weeks of unglamorous work. Doing it before you start raising is worth more than almost anything else you could do with those weeks.

What a clean cap table actually means

One authoritative record exists, and everyone involved agrees which one it is. Not three versions in three inboxes, and not a file your accountant maintains separately from the one your lawyer maintains.

It distinguishes authorized shares from issued shares. Authorized is the ceiling in your charter. Issued is what actually exists in someone's hands. Owners routinely quote one and mean the other, which makes every percentage in the conversation wrong.

It shows the fully diluted count: issued shares, plus every option granted, plus every option still unissued in the pool, plus every warrant, plus everything convertible into stock. That is the denominator investors use, and it is the only denominator that describes your real ownership.

And every holder on it has signed paper in a folder. A stock purchase agreement, a grant notice, a note, a SAFE. If the company took property or services instead of cash for shares, the document says so.

The record also has to match the entity. If the business started as one company and later moved into another, somebody has to be able to show how the shares travelled and who approved the move. A spreadsheet that begins at the current entity and quietly ignores the two years before it is a gap, and it tends to be the first gap a diligence lawyer finds, because it is close to the first thing they look for.

The defects that stop a round

These are the ones that turn up repeatedly in real files.

Each of these is repairable. Each one is much harder to repair once a priced round is in motion and the person you need a signature from knows it.

The promise nobody papered

Almost every business has one of these. A friend who built the first version of the product, an advisor who made the introduction that started everything, a former partner who was told they would get a piece.

The conversation happened. Nothing was signed. Both sides remember it differently, and both are being honest.

Deal with it now, while there is no valuation on the table and no incoming investor watching. A written agreement for a modest number of shares, signed today, is cheap. The same conversation after a term sheet arrives is a negotiation with someone who has learned that your timeline is the pressure point.

Where the person is genuinely gone and the promise was vague, a signed release is worth asking for. Where the promise was real, honor it and document it. What you cannot do is leave it unresolved and hope the question does not come up, because the question always comes up, and it comes up in writing from a law firm.

Sizing the pool before the conversation

Investors will require an option pool, and they will want it created before their money goes in, which means it dilutes you rather than them.

You have more control over this term than over the valuation, and owners consistently spend their effort on the wrong one.

Build a hiring plan for the next eighteen months. Actual roles, with the equity each one would reasonably receive. Total it. That number, defended with a document, is a much stronger position than accepting a round percentage because it is what the form says. A pool two points smaller than requested puts two points back in your column, permanently.

Write the plan down even when the number feels obvious. A pool argued from a hiring list is a conversation about the business. A pool argued from a percentage is a conversation about who blinks, and you will lose that one, because the person across the table has had it many times and you have had it once.

The file you should be able to hand over

Assemble one folder, before anyone asks for it.

The charter and every amendment. The board consents and shareholder consents that authorized each issuance. A signed agreement for every holder on the table. Every option grant, with the date it was issued, the exercise price, and the schedule it vests on. Every convertible instrument with its cap and discount. Proof of payment where shares were bought. The 83(b) filings with their mailing evidence.

Then have your lawyer reconcile the folder against the spreadsheet, line by line, and tell you where they disagree. They will disagree somewhere. That is the point of doing it now, in a quiet week, rather than during the week you are trying to close.

Then decide, in one sentence, who owns this going forward. A cap table falls out of date the week after it is cleaned, because a grant gets approved on a call and written up later, or never. Pick one person. Give them a single rule, that no share moves without a signed document reaching the file, and have them reconcile the spreadsheet against the board consents every quarter. That habit costs an hour every three months. The version of this problem you fix during diligence costs a discount on your valuation.

Common questions

what is a clean cap table

One authoritative record in which every holder traces back to a signed document and, where shares were purchased, to evidence that money changed hands. It separates authorized shares from issued shares and shows the fully diluted count. Everyone involved agrees on which file is the real one.

what is an 83b election and when is it due

It is an election under Internal Revenue Code section 83(b) to be taxed on restricted stock at grant rather than as it vests. The filing deadline is thirty days from the transfer and it is strict. Confirm the date and the filing with your own tax adviser rather than from memory.

how big should my option pool be before a seed round

Size it against a written hiring plan for the next eighteen months rather than accepting a round percentage. Total the equity each planned role would reasonably receive, and defend that number. A pool created before the round dilutes existing holders, so every point of it comes from you.

More on this