The Capital Stack Room Who gets paid first, and what that position costs.

The Capital Stack Room

FOLLOW-ON RIGHTS

Pro Rata Rights: What They Cost You Two Rounds Later

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

Pro rata rights cost nothing in the round where you sign them and cost you real ownership two rounds later, when the next lead needs its target stake.

In the middle of a seed document there is a sentence about one page long that gives an investor the right to buy their share of your next round. It reads like housekeeping. Your lawyer may not flag it. The investor will describe it as standard, and by the common meaning of that word, it is.

Pro rata rights let an existing holder put money into future financings in an amount sufficient to keep their ownership percentage from falling. If they own 20 percent before the round, they may buy 20 percent of the new shares being issued.

The clause costs you nothing in the round where you sign it. It costs you in the round after that, and the cost shows up somewhere most owners are not looking: in the size of the round, rather than in the price.

Round one: it genuinely costs you nothing

Work through the first exercise and you will see why nobody objects.

Say that after your seed you hold 70 percent, a seed investor holds 20, and the option pool holds 10. You raise a Series A that sells 25 percent of the company to new money.

If the seed investor exercises pro rata, they buy 20 percent of that new issuance, which is five points of the post-round company. Their old stake dilutes from 20 to 15, the five new points bring them back to 20, and the outside lead takes the remaining 20 points. You go from 70 to 52.5.

If the seed investor passes entirely, the outside lead takes all 25 points. You still go from 70 to 52.5.

Your number is identical either way. Pro rata does not take shares from you in that round. It takes allocation from the incoming investor, which is why founders sign it without much thought and why incoming investors are the ones who complain about it.

Round two: where the bill arrives

Now run the Series B, and the mechanism turns around.

You hold 52.5 percent. The seed investor holds 20, the Series A lead holds 20, the pool holds 7.5. A new lead wants 20 percent of the company after the round, because that is the position their fund requires to make the investment work.

Suppose the seed investor exercises its pro rata and the Series A lead passes. The seed investor is entitled to 20 percent of whatever gets issued. If the company issues exactly 20 points, the new lead ends up with 16 of them and refuses the deal.

So the round gets bigger. For the lead to land on 20 points while the seed takes its 20 percent share of the issuance, the company has to issue 25 points rather than 20. Everyone holding shares before the round dilutes by a quarter instead of a fifth.

Your 52.5 percent becomes 39.4 instead of 42. You lost 2.6 points of a company you already owned, and you lost them to a term you agreed to two years earlier in a document about a different round.

Put a price on that. If the business eventually sells for 60,000,000 dollars, 2.6 points is about 1,560,000. The clause was one sentence long.

There is a second version of the same squeeze. Instead of growing the round, the new lead holds the size and pushes the valuation down to get the ownership it needs. Same outcome, arriving through the price rather than the share count, and harder to see.

A third version happens more often than either. The new lead simply asks you to go and get the existing holders to waive. Now you are the one making the call, asking an investor who backed you early to give up a right they bargained for, a few days before a closing you need. That conversation has a cost even when it works, and the cost gets paid in the relationship rather than on the cap table.

What the right is, and what it is not

Two clarifications save a lot of confused conversations later.

A pro rata right is an option, never an obligation. The holder may exercise it or let it go, and nothing in the document requires them to put in another dollar. The company gets no funding certainty out of the clause at all. It is a right held against you with no matching commitment running the other way.

A contractual pro rata right is also a different thing from a preemptive right sitting in your charter or arising under your state's corporate statute. One is a promise made to a named investor in a specific agreement. The other can attach to an entire class of shareholders, including people you have not thought about in years.

Ask your lawyer which of the two you have. The answer changes who must be offered shares in the next round, and what happens if you skip them. An issuance made without honoring a preemptive right can be challenged afterward, and discovering that during diligence is a bad week.

The costs that do not appear in any model

Three other things ride along with this clause, and none of them is arithmetic.

An investor holding pro rata who declines to exercise sends a message. New investors notice when the people closest to the business pass on buying more of it. The right to participate creates a moment where not participating means something, and that moment happens during your fundraise.

A transferable pro rata right can end up held by somebody you never chose. Rights that move with the shares can put a stranger, or a competitor's affiliate, in a position to buy into your next round.

And super pro rata, which is the right to buy more than the holder's existing percentage, is a different instrument wearing a similar name. It lets an early investor take a large share of a later round on terms negotiated by someone else. If you see that phrase, treat it as a major term and not a variation on a standard one.

What to negotiate, and what to let go

Do not try to strike pro rata entirely from a seed document. You will spend credibility on an argument you are unlikely to win, and the right is reasonable on its face.

Negotiate the boundaries instead.

Limit it to major investors, with the threshold defined by a minimum dollar amount invested. A dozen small holders each entitled to a slice of every future round is an administrative problem that lands on you at the worst possible time.

Make it non-transferable, so the right stays with the person you agreed to give it to.

Add a sunset, so the right ends after a stated round or a stated financing size. Rights written for a seed stage rarely make sense at a growth stage, and nobody objects to this in advance the way they object to it later.

Refuse super pro rata unless you are getting something specific for it.

Watch for the same right appearing in a side letter rather than in the main agreement. Side letters travel badly. One person signs them, they get filed somewhere separate, and everybody forgets about them except the holder, who produces the letter two rounds later at the moment it matters. Whatever you agree to, make sure it lands in the document your lawyer maintains.

Then write the clause into the same file where you keep your cap table, with a note on what it will cost at the next two rounds. This is a term whose consequences arrive years after the conversation that created it, and by then, the only people who remember the conversation are the ones it favors.

Common questions

what are pro rata rights in a term sheet

They let an existing investor buy enough of a future round to keep their ownership percentage from falling. The right is an option rather than an obligation, so the holder can walk away from it. It costs you nothing in the round where you grant it.

do pro rata rights hurt founders

Not in the round where they get exercised, because the allocation comes out of the incoming investor rather than out of you. The cost lands at the next round, when a new lead needs a target stake and the round has to grow to deliver it. That extra issuance dilutes everyone who already held shares.

should i give pro rata rights to a seed investor

Usually yes, since the request is reasonable and fighting it spends credibility you will want elsewhere. Bound it instead. Limit the right to major investors and add a sunset, so a seed stage term does not survive into a growth stage financing.

More on this