The Capital Stack Room Who gets paid first, and what that position costs.

The Capital Stack Room

COST OF CAPITAL

When Debt Is Cheaper Than Equity, and When That Stops Being True

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

Debt costs a number you can read off a page while equity costs a share of every future dollar, so the real question is which one your cash can carry.

Somebody told you debt is cheaper than equity. They were right, as arithmetic, and the sentence still gets owners into trouble, because it describes a price without describing the conditions attached to paying it.

Debt costs a number you can read off a page. Interest, fees, and the value of whatever you pledged. That number is finite and it ends on a date. Equity costs a share of every dollar the business ever produces or sells for, which is an unknown number and usually a much larger one. On that comparison alone, borrowing wins almost every time.

The comparison is incomplete, and the missing piece is what happens when you are wrong about the year ahead. Debt is cheaper when the business can pay it out of cash it already makes and the bad case does not end the company. It stops being cheaper the moment the payment starts competing with payroll.

The comparison almost nobody runs

Put both options on the same page with the same amount of money.

You need 500,000 dollars. The loan option is a five year amortizing note. For the sake of the arithmetic, say it carries 11 percent. That is roughly 10,900 dollars a month, and across the full term you repay about 652,000, of which 152,000 is interest. The rate here is an input to an example, not a quoted price. Yours depends on what secures the loan, how long you have been operating, and how much cash sits above the payment.

The equity option is selling 20 percent of the business for the same 500,000, which prices the company at 2,500,000 after the money goes in.

Now imagine two endings.

In the first, the business does well and sells in six years for 6,000,000 dollars. The investor's 20 percent is worth 1,200,000. The loan, had you taken it, cost 152,000 and was gone after year five. Debt was cheaper by more than a million dollars, and it is not close.

In the second ending, the business struggles and sells for 1,500,000. The investor's stake is worth 300,000, so they lost 200,000 of the money they gave you. The lender, meanwhile, collected all 652,000 on schedule, and if you missed a payment along the way it had remedies that did not require your consent.

Same two instruments. The cheaper one changed depending on an outcome neither of you could see from where you were standing.

What debt charges that is not interest

The rate is the part everyone compares. It is rarely the expensive part.

A loan usually brings collateral, which means an asset you rely on now answers to somebody else. It usually brings a personal guarantee, which moves the risk off the company and onto your household, and which outlives the business. It often brings covenants, which are promises about ratios and behavior that convert an ordinary bad quarter into a technical default.

And it brings a payment date that does not care about your customers. That last one is the real cost. Equity has no date. A lender's patience is written down in advance and does not extend because the reason was good.

The stated rate leaves things out as well. Origination fees come off the top, so you receive less than the face amount while paying interest on all of it. Some facilities carry a prepayment charge, which means clearing the loan early costs money. A short term facility that has to be renewed is not really a fixed cost at all, because the renewal happens at whatever price and whatever appetite exist on that future date, and by then you will have built a business around the assumption that it continues.

None of this makes borrowing wrong. It makes borrowing a commitment about the future stability of your cash, and the price you are quoted says nothing about whether you can make that commitment honestly.

The coverage test

Before comparing prices, find out whether you can carry the payment at all. There is one honest way to do it.

Take your worst month in the past two years, not your average month. Subtract everything that had to be paid that month. Then subtract the new payment. If the result is a number you could have survived without borrowing again, the debt is serviceable. If it is not, the loan has not made your business cheaper. It has made your business fragile at a discount.

Run the same test on your slowest season rather than a single month if your revenue moves in cycles. A landscaping business and a tax practice both have quarters where the money is simply not there, and an amortizing payment does not know that.

Lenders run their own version of this and call it coverage. You should run it first, because they are measuring whether they get repaid and you are measuring whether you keep the business.

When equity is the honest answer

There are situations where selling ownership is the correct call and not a concession.

When the payback period is long. Money spent building something that produces revenue in year three cannot service a payment in month two, and pretending otherwise just moves the failure later.

When there is nothing to pledge. A business whose value sits in relationships and know-how has little a lender can take, which is exactly why the lender will want your house instead.

When the use of the money is a bet rather than a purchase. Buying a second truck for a route you already run is a calculation. Entering a market you have never sold into is a bet, and a bet financed with a fixed payment gets settled with your personal assets.

And when the amount required is large relative to current revenue. A loan sized to your ambition rather than your cash flow is the most common way a decent business gets taken apart.

And when the guarantee is the part you cannot accept. A business risk and a household risk are two different decisions, and a personal guarantee converts the first into the second. Owners who have already lost money once tend to price that conversion correctly. Owners raising for the first time often sign it because it appeared on page nine of a document they were relieved to be offered at all.

Most real stacks are both

The framing of debt against equity is cleaner in an article than it is on a balance sheet.

A working answer is often equity or equity-like money for the part that is genuinely uncertain, and debt for the part that is a purchase with a measurable return. Finance the truck with a note. Finance the two years of building the thing nobody has bought yet with ownership.

The order matters too. A senior lender will usually have something to say about new debt taken on later, and a preferred investor will usually hold consent rights over it. So the sequence in which you raise sets the permissions you will need next time. Borrowing first and raising equity second is a different life from raising equity first and borrowing second, even when the two stacks end up looking identical on paper. Ask, at every financing, who will have to approve the one after it.

That split also protects the equity you sell. Every dollar you raise at today's valuation is the most expensive dollar you will ever take, because it is priced before the work that makes the business worth more. Borrowing for the things that can carry a payment leaves the ownership available for the things that cannot.

Write down which category each expense belongs to before you go looking for money. Most owners discover they need less equity than they assumed, and they discover it in time to matter.

Common questions

is debt cheaper than equity for a small business

As arithmetic, usually. Interest is a finite number that ends on a date, while equity takes a share of every dollar the business ever produces. That comparison only holds if the business can make the payment through a bad season without borrowing again.

how do i know if my business can afford a loan payment

Take your worst month or your slowest season from the past two years rather than your average. Subtract everything that had to be paid, then subtract the new payment. If what remains would have carried you through without new borrowing, the loan is serviceable.

when should a business raise equity instead of borrowing

When the payback period is long, when there is nothing to pledge as collateral, or when the money funds a bet rather than a purchase with a measurable return. A fixed payment set against an uncertain outcome is a common way a decent business gets taken apart.

More on this